Weird & indulgent

I stuck with this, thinking it might improve. Alas, no… it was so self indulgent at times and pompous. Certain elements were obscure and disjointed and so difficult to follow the narrative. Also it was almost impossible to feel any connection with the characters. I think it may have helped to have been narrated by a female voice rather than the ponderous way this was delivered.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Overall it’s a good story

It’s a good story. However it is a little slow in places. The narrative is good. It’s interesting to hear the story behind the musical.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Relly good writing and carachter development

Bizarre gaps, the protagonists last chapter sudden derangement (ummm like Game of Thrones). Without spoiling, iMagine the witch descending on her broom to confront Dorothy then...She is waking from a hangover. Sorry thats a cheap cheat. The final ending results in the witches encounter with the film version bucket of water. but only after acting like a complete lunatic...this from the most rational carachter in the story. I was hoping for a better finish, the book is exceptional otherwise, truly so.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Powerful and Moving

I didn't realise before reading this how closely racism and civil rights were going to be explored in this. Its really interesting how this is tired into the narrative.

I also love the mix of characters in age, race and background, surprisingly diverse. There are also hints and some or prominent mentions of LGBT+ characters/relationships/acts. This again is surprisingly. But to me at least this fits well and doesn't seem forced or out of place.

There is some brilliant world building and the way different creation myths are explored is really interesting. For a story with a lot of characters it doesn't feel overcrowded and for me at least it was fairly easy to keep track of them. I like how having been introduced and having built an emotional attachment to certain characters in the early chapters. We then jump forward serveral years and only learn of the fate of these characters in a very off hand way. This was extremely powerful and moving.

On a different note I was surprised by how much sex and reference to sex there was in this book. It also uses some interesting menaphors and positions. Again not what I was expecting. This is definitely not a children's book.

There is just so much packed into this book. But another thing I must mention is the was religion is portrayed in this. It is approached from so many different angles and view points. It's really interesting.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Definitely not for children

Not at all what I expected, but a detailed, shocking story of Oz.
I haven’t seen the musical but I imagine there’s not a lot of this book in a family show.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Great listen

Puts a totally different light on the original story, just begs the question" who was really Wicked ?????? " it's up to you to decide !!!!!!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Not as expected - which is a good thing!

Surprisingly darker, different to what the musical shows and makes me want to explore the rest of the series, at least the sequel.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Still one of my absolute faves.

I've listened more times than I can remember now and each time I spot something I've missed. the narration is fab. the storyline speaks to my soul. Just brilliant 👏

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Perfect narration, mid book

The narration is great if a little slow but the book itself is very mediocre. There is no need to compare it with the musical as the musical is just a really loose adaptation of the book, a fanfiction even. The world is purely built as a vessel for the authors political commentary. It has dark themes and gets really creepy at times. Even though the protagonist is a female character, the author can't seem to be able to write women (nor their relationships) as three dimensional, interesting and complex beings. Fiyero was better written and had more character development than Elphaba.... It's an ok book, nothing groundbreaking. Do not recommend anyone under 14 to read it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A beautiful imagination that leaves further intrigue

Such a beautiful retelling, a perspective even, that leaves the listener/reader asking more questions to no answers. I look forward to hearing the rest of the series!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!