Humanistic story in a mathematics settting.

This is a case when the book would be useful. You need diagrams to keep some of the plot in your head. There is an interactive web tool to see how objects behave which is really fun to play with. So the setting is just awesome and the idea to put a real human story into is great, but the only think lacking was that the overall story line was not as robust and cleanly executed as it might have been. Perhaps it is an intrinsic problem with wanting a story to be told when the maths is the main reason for telling it. Definitely read it, but don't worry about the ending.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Very Interesting Premise

If I hadn't read the blurb first, I would have been confused and annoyed.

Plot seems very secondary, main purpose of the book is to explore the world Egan creates. Although this universe really is fascinating, I think the plot didn't get its dues, and in my opinion, the ending is cut short. I wish I could give 3.5 stars for plot, as it really is a close thing for me.

I liked all the characters, and the developments in the Sider/Walker relationships were just as fascinating as the wider universal physics.

Google the book to read his website about the Dichronauts universe, was a great help in understanding the reasons behind things.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Unsatisfying

Generally I find Greg Egan's hard Sci-Fi thought provoking and enlightening, even without knowing all the math behind the universes his stories paint they still stand up as great stories, and there's enough description to paint a picture of the world and it's usually unusual physics in vivid Technicolor, this book was a departure from the norm, the universe the book is predicated on is lacking any explanation within the book and even after studying the physics on his website it was still as clear as mud for a while. While the story thread itself seems to be well put together to a point as an exploration of the universe it inhabits the conclusion is lacking, with little to tie off the dangling plot threads the reader or listener is left to imagine a happily ever after a fairy tale ending to a not very fairy tale plot so far.

Spoilers ahead

Geometry, the book is predicated on a novel geometry with a universe based on 2 time dimensions (hence dichrone from the books title) and 2 space ones but one of the time dimensions isn't explained to be as such and is treated like a space dimension where turning into it is impossible and skews your perspective. The physics does seem to hold as true but there's no exploration of the 2nd time dimension as anything but a novel spacial one. And since it's not explained at all in the text at some point you will go looking on the web for the explanation on Greg's website for why the universe acts the way it does.

Plot, the book's plot is well crafted as an exploration of the world of the protagonist, a shifting axis in effect causing the creatures in the book to migrate with the seasons being the setup for the society and our intrepid dichronauts being some of the people who map the world in advance of the migration. The protagonists are a dual symbiotic entity that rely on one another in a way to provide the vision in their blind dimension(s) but they lack for a good long while a full description that allows you to picture them in the mind's eye. They become surveyors and map the world for the migration and one is clearly a genius because from first principles he figures out, A hot air balloons, B the way the sun orbits the world and the way the world rotates to explain the migration (though without enough detail to let the reader grasp that without the website foot notes) C the edge of the world hypothesis, D more, mostly from first principles. There's moral and personal dilemmas and after getting some real answers about the world and just as the whole thing seemed ready to get resolved the book ends with no conclusion. No epilogue, it just ends. Almost right as the action seems set to start again but with no resolution to the lost companions on the way, no resolution to the thread of what would be done about the migration with the information available. No real resolution of the moral dilemma. The ending being implied to be and everyone lives happily ever after, the people who got lost on the journey made it home and that the protagonist makes it home without further trouble (in spite of a challenging journey ahead) that the moral issue is resolved by something and more questions than answers.

So it just ends with so many unsatisfactory dangling threads I can't really recommend the book at all.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful